RESOLUTION MEPC.391(81)

(adopted on 22 March 2024)

 

2024 GUIDELINES ON LIFE CYCLE GHG INTENSITY OF MARINE FUELS (2024 LCA GUIDELINES)

 

THE MARINE ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION COMMITTEE,

 

RECALLING Article 38(a) of the Convention on the International Maritime Organization concerning the functions of the Marine Environment Protection Committee conferred upon it by international conventions for the prevention and control of marine pollution from ships,

 

RECALLING ALSO that, at its eightieth session, it adopted, by resolution MEPC.377(80), the 2023 IMO Strategy on Reduction of GHG Emissions from Ships (2023 IMO GHG Strategy) setting out the levels of ambition for the international shipping sector in reducing GHG emissions,

 

RECALLING FURTHER that, at its eightieth session, it also adopted, by resolution MEPC.376(80), Guidelines on life cycle GHG intensity of marine fuels (LCA Guidelines);

 

NOTING that the 2023 IMO GHG Strategy provides that the levels of ambition and indicative checkpoints set out therein should take into account the well-to-wake GHG emissions of marine fuels as addressed in the LCA Guidelines,

 

NOTING ALSO that the 2023 IMO GHG Strategy provides that the basket of candidate mid-term GHG reduction measures should take into account the well-to-wake GHG emissions of marine fuels as addressed in the LCA Guidelines,

 

HAVING CONSIDERED, at its eighty-first session, draft 2024 Guidelines on life cycle GHG intensity of marine fuels,

 

1          ADOPTS the 2024 Guidelines on life cycle GHG intensity of marine fuels (2024 LCA Guidelines), as set out in the annex to the present resolution;

 

2          AGREES that any regulatory application and implications of the 2024 LCA Guidelines should be determined by the Committee in the process of developing regulatory provisions,

 

3          REQUESTS Member Governments to bring the annexed Guidelines to the attention of shipowners, ship operators, shipbuilders, ship designers, energy companies, fuel producers, bunkering companies, engine manufacturers and any other interested parties;

 

4          AGREES to keep these Guidelines under review in light of experience gained with their implementation;

 

5          REVOKES the LCA Guidelines adopted by resolution MEPC.376(80).

 

2024 GUIDELINES ON LIFE CYCLE GHG INTENSITY OF MARINE FUELS (2024 LCA Guidelines)

 

CONTENTS

 

PART I: GENERAL

 

1          INTRODUCTION

 

2          SCOPE

 

PART II: METHODOLOGY

 

3          GENERAL APPROACH

 

4          WELL-TO-TANK (WtT)

 

5          TANK-TO-WAKE (TtW)

 

6          WELL-TO-WAKE (WtW)

 

7          SUSTAINABILITY

 

8          FUEL LIFECYCLE LABEL (FLL)

 

PART III: DEFAULT EMISSION FACTORS AND ACTUAL VALUES

 

9          DEFAULT EMISSION FACTORS

 

10        ACTUAL EMISSION FACTORS

 

PART IV: VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION

 

11        ELEMENTS SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION/CERTIFICATION

 

12        IDENTIFICATION OF CERTIFICATION SCHEMES/STANDARDS

 

PART V: REVIEW

 

13        CONTINUOUS REVIEW PROCESS

         

APPENDIX 1      FUEL LIST WITH FUEL PATHWAY CODE

APPENDIX 2      INITIAL DEFAULT EMISSION FACTORS PER FUEL PATHWAY CODE

APPENDIX 3      ABBREVIATIONS AND GLOSSARY

APPENDIX 4      TEMPLATE FOR WELL-TO-TANK DEFAULT EMISSION FACTOR SUBMISSION 

APPENDIX 5      TEMPLATE FOR TANK-TO-WAKE DEFAULT EMISSION FACTOR SUBMISSION

 

PART I: GENERAL

 

1          INTRODUCTION

 

These Guidelines provide guidance on life cycle GHG intensity assessment for all fuels and other energy carriers (e.g. electricity) used on board a ship and aim at covering the whole fuel life cycle (with specific boundaries), from feedstock extraction/cultivation/ recovery, feedstock conversion to a fuel product, transportation as well as distribution/bunkering, and fuel utilization on board a ship. These Guidelines also specify sustainability themes/aspects for marine fuels and define a Fuel Lifecycle Label (FLL), which carries information about fuel type, feedstock (feedstock type and feedstock nature/carbon source), conversion/production process (process type and energy used in the process), GHG emission factors, information on fuel blends and sustainability themes/aspects. These Guidelines specify the elements of FLL subject to verification/certification and include a general procedure on how the certification scheme/standards could be identified.

 

2          SCOPE

 

2.1       The scope of these Guidelines is to address well-to-tank (WtT), tank-to wake (TtW), and well-to-wake (WtW) GHG intensity and sustainability themes/aspects related to marine fuels/energy carriers (e.g. electricity for shore power) used for ship propulsion and power generation onboard. The relevant GHGs included are carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O). These guidelines are not intended to provide guidance for a complete IMO GHG inventory for international shipping. Emissions from cargo (e.g. volatile organic compounds (VOC)), or use of refrigerants are not included; other short-lived climate forcers and precursors such as non-methane volatile organic compounds (NMVOC), sulphur oxides (SOx), carbon monoxide (CO), particulate matter (PM) and Black Carbon are not part of the scope of these LCA guidelines.

 

2.2       The system boundaries of the WtW GHG emission factors calculation, in the context of these guidelines span the life cycle of fuels from their sourcing to production, conversion, transport, distribution, and eventually their use on board ships based on an attributional approach.1 The possibility to expand the system boundaries for specific pathways in which the feedstock is displaced from present use(s) will be assessed on a case-by-case basis.2 As such, emissions associated with the following life cycle stages of the fuel life cycle chain will be accounted for:

_________________

1     Attributional Life Cycle Assessment (LCA): LCA aiming to describe the environmentally relevant physical flows to and from a system and its subsystems over their life cycle; Consequential Life cycle Analysis (LCA): LCA aiming to describe how environmentally relevant flows will change in response to possible decisions. (Finnveden G, Hauschild MZ, Ekvall T, Guinée J, Heijungs R, Hellweg S, et al. "Recent developments in life cycle assessment". Journal of Environmental Management. 2009;91(1):1-21).

 

2     Such as for captured CO2 transportation and storage.

 

.1       feedstock extraction/cultivation/acquisition/recovery;

.2       feedstock (early) processing/ transformation at source;

.3       feedstock transport to conversion site;

.4       feedstock conversion to product fuel;

.5       product fuel transport/storage/delivery/retail storage/bunkering; and

.6       fuel utilization on board a ship.

 

2.3       Consistent with the attributional approach and using best available scientific evidence, the WtT emissions calculations (i.e. emissions related to the fuel sourcing, production, conversion, transport and delivery) are assessed regardless of the final use of fuels/energy carriers, and the TtW emissions (i.e. emissions related to the fuel use) are quantified regardless of the sourcing/production/conversion/transport and delivery steps of the fuel/energy carrier. WtW emissions are given by the sum of the two parts, providing the full emission performance associated with the fuel production and use of a certain fuel/energy in a specific converter onboard.

 

2.4       The GHG emissions are calculated as CO2-equivalent (CO2eq), using the global warming potential over a 100-year time-horizon (GWP100) to convert emissions of other gases than CO2, as given in the fifth IPCC Assessment Report,3 for CO2, CH4 and N2O, as follows:

_________________

3     The global warming potential values as given in the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) are used in the context of these Guidelines.

 

 

These GWP100 values should be used for the purpose of quantifying the GHG intensity in accordance with these guidelines.

 

A calculation using a global warming potential over a 20-year horizon (GWP20) may be provided as information for comparative purposes, as follows:

 

 

2.5       These Guidelines provide:

 

.1       WtW GHG emission factors based on a life cycle attributional methodology, expressing the GHG profile of each representative fuel using on global warming potential (GWP) values over a 100-year time-horizon of included GHG (CO2, CH4 and N2O);

 

.2       WtT GHG emission factors (CO2, CH4 and N2O) quantified consistently with the attributional approach;

 

.3       TtW GHG emission factors (CO2, CH4 and N2O); and

 

.4       sustainability themes/aspects for marine fuels.

 

2.6       These Guidelines define a FLL that carries information about fuel type, feedstock used, fuel production pathway, GHG emission factors, information on fuel blends and sustainability themes/aspects.

 

2.7       The figure below shows a generic WtW supply chain for a fuel. The bunkering marks the last step in the WtT phase before the TtW phase starts.

 

Figure 1: Generic well-to-wake supply chain

 

2.8       These Guidelines include an initial non-exhaustive list of fuels in appendix 1, depicting the main current and expected future marine fuels.

 

PART II: METHODOLOGY

 

3          GENERAL APPROACH

 

3.1       A life cycle assessment (LCA) based approach provides a holistic assessment of the product/service/system from well-to-wake using data specific to the activity considered. The LCA methodology follows the marine fuel from feedstock sourcing to its utilization onboard ships and assesses its life cycle GHG intensity. This approach, applied within the boundaries of the WtW GHG emissions quantification, is applicable across all geographical regions, where emissions occur and allows for quantifying the GHG intensity over the entire fuel/energy supply chain.

 

3.2       General principles and methodology can be found in ISO 14044:2006 Environmental management — Lifecycle assessment — Requirements and guidelines. ISO 14040:2006 Environmental management — Lifecycle assessment — Principles and framework sets the framework for the LCA, for the quantification of the environmental impact of products, processes and services in the supply chain. On this basis, a specific LCA methodology can be tailored for its application to marine fuels.

 

3.3       WtT emissions represent GHG emissions resulting from growing or extracting raw materials, producing and transporting the fuel up to the point of use, including bunkering.

 

3.4       TtW emissions represent GHG emissions resulting from fuel utilization onboard (e.g. combustion), including potential leaks (fugitive emissions and slip), when relevant for the GHG assessment.

 

3.5       WtW emissions are the sum of the WtT and TtW emissions and quantify the full life cycle GHG emissions for a given fuel and fuel pathway, used in a given energy converter on board.

 

3.6       The attributional approach considers all processes along the supply chain of fuel/energy carrier pathways, allowing the quantification of contributions per segment to the overall GHG intensity of the final fuel/energy product used on board a ship. The expansion of the system boundaries for specific pathways, in which the feedstock or intermediate products are diverted from existing use(s), may be considered on a case-by-case basis.

 

3.7       As regards the expansion of the system boundaries, with consequential elements such as Indirect Land Usage Change (ILUC), concerns with respect to uncertainties and the risk of arbitrariness suggest that the feedstocks with associated ILUC should only be assessed through a risk-based approach, in the framework of sustainability themes/aspects, as part of these guidelines.

 

3.8       When more than one product results from a conversion process, emissions related to the fuel production should be allocated between main product and co-products. Within such conversion processes, emissions are allocated using their energy content, the so-called "energy allocation" approach. Where co-products allocation cannot be performed based on their energy content (e.g. Oxygen resulting from water electrolysis for H2 production), other methods such as mass allocation, market revenue allocation (also known as "economic allocation"), could be considered on a case-by-case basis.

 

3.9       A co-product is defined as "an outcome of a production process, which has economic value and elastic supply (intended as the existence of a clear evidence of the causal link between feedstock market value and the quantity of feedstock that can be produced)".

 

3.10     This definition applies also when a raw material used to produce the fuels is a waste (no economic value) or a residue (unavoidably produced and with negligible economic value, needing further processing to be used in the main conversion process). In case the feedstock is a waste, a residue or a by-product, emissions considered as WtT start at the feedstock collection point onwards until the point of use of the final fuel/energy product.

 

3.11     According to the IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories (IPCC Guidelines)4, any carbon in the fuel derived from biomass should be reported as an information item and not included in the sectoral or national totals to avoid double counting, since the net emissions from biomass are already accounted for in the Agriculture Forestry and Other Land Use (AFOLU) sector at a national level.

___________________

4     2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories.

 

3.12     The scope of the IMO LCA Guidelines does not affect or change the IPCC Guidelines. According to the IPCC Guidelines, international waterborne navigation (international bunkers) is grouped under "Mobile combustion" under the Energy sector, but emissions from fuel used by ships in international transport should not be included in national totals in national GHG inventories.

 

3.13     A fuel batch may be a mix of fuels made from various feedstocks and sources (e.g. by blending 20% biodiesel into fossil MGO) and/or through different production pathways. The calculation should be done using the weighted averages of the energy of the various fuel components. Relevant information should accompany each component fuel in the FLL. Blended fuels should be included in the certification schemes and relevant GHG default or actual emission factors (gCO2/MJ) determined in proportion to the energy of each fuel part of the blend.

 

4          WELL-TO-TANK (WtT)

 

4.1       The pathway of each relevant marine fuel should be clearly described and the GHG emissions during each step of the fuel pathway should be calculated. Specific GHG emissions of a specific non-conventional and non-fossil fuel's pathway may take into account different characteristics across geographic regions, where feedstock production and/or conversion occurs, as appropriate.

 

4.2       Any further reference in this document to a "fuel pathway" should be understood to include the feedstock structure (the so-called nature/carbon source and feedstock type pair) and the production or conversion process (noting that the same feedstock and fuel type pair can have a different production or conversion process).

 

4.3       The aim of the WtT methodology is to quantify and evaluate the GHG intensity of fuel production, including all steps mentioned in figure 2. The carbon feedstock and production pathway of a fuel should be identified in order to apply the methodology and is included as part of the FLL. The production steps to be included in the WtT are presented in figure 2.

 

Figure 2: Generic well-to-tank supply chain

 

4.4       The WtT GHG emission factor (gCO2eq/MJ(LCV) fuel or electricity) is calculated according to Equation (1).

 

Equation (1)

 

 

Term

Units

Explanation

𝑒𝑓𝑒𝑐𝑢

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions associated with the feedstock

extraction/cultivation/acquisition/recovery

𝑒𝑙

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions (annualized emissions (over 20 years) from carbon stock changes caused by direct land-use change)5

𝑒𝑝

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions associated with the feedstock processing and/or transformation at source and emissions associated with the conversion of the feedstock to the final fuel product, including electricity generation

𝑒𝑡𝑑

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions associated with the feedstock transport to conversion plant, and the emissions associated with the finished fuel transport and storage, local delivery, retail storage and bunkering

𝑒𝑠𝑐𝑎

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions (annualized emission savings (over 20 years) from soil carbon accumulation via improved agricultural management)6

𝑒𝑐𝑐𝑠

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions credit from carbon capture and storage (eccs), that have not already been accounted for in ep. This should properly account the avoided emissions through the capture and sequestration of emitted CO2, related to the extraction, transport, processing and distribution of fuel (csc). From the above-mentioned emission credit, all the emissions resulting from the process of capturing (ecc) and transporting (et) the CO2 up to the final storage (including the emissions related to the injection, etc.) need to be deducted.

This element should be calculated with the following formula:

 

eccs = csc −ecc −et − est −ex

𝑐𝑠𝑐

g CO2 stored /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions credit equivalent to the net CO2 captured and stored (long-term: 100 years)

𝑒𝑐𝑐

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions associated with the process of capturing, compression and/or cooling and temporary storage of the CO2

𝑒𝑡

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Emissions associated with transport to a long-term storage site

𝑒𝑠𝑡

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Any emissions associated with the process of storing (longterm: 100 years) the captured CO2 (including fugitive emissions that may happen during long-term storage and/or the injection of CO2 into the storage)

𝑒𝑥

gCO2eq /

MJ(LCV)

Any additional emissions related to the CCS

___________________

5     Pending further methodological guidance to be developed by the Organization, the value of parameter el should be set to zero.

 

6     Pending further methodological guidance to be developed by the Organization, the value of parameter esca should be set to zero.

 

4.5       The WtT emissions in Equation (1) include emissions associated with raw materials extraction or cultivation, primary energy sources used for production of goods and utilities such as energy carriers (e.g. fuels and electricity), transport and distribution (including bunkering), direct land use change and changes in carbon stocks (soil carbon accumulation).

 

4.6       Processing incorporates all steps and operations needed for the extraction, capture or cultivation of the primary energy source. Process includes basic transformation at source and operations needed to make the resource transportable to the marketplace (e.g. drying, chemical/physical upgrade such as gas-to-liquid, etc.).

 

4.7       Transportation, processing and distribution include transportation of the products in the fuel pathway to the place of transformation, conditioning (such as compression, cooling), distribution to the marketplace (i.e. bunkering) and eventual leakages, as well as fugitive emissions at any of these stages. Regarding emissions from bunkering, it is included till the bunker manifold, including emission from the bunker manifold connection.

 

4.8       Allocation of emissions to co-products based on their energy content should be used, as the most appropriate and reliable methodology considering the establishment of an appropriate certification method using values that are predictable, reproducible and stable.

 

4.9       Land use (direct and indirect) for the production of biofuels may lead to land use change (LUC). LUC can be classified as direct LUC (DLUC) and indirect LUC (ILUC).

 

4.10     The DLUC definition is based on ISO 14067:2018 described as a change in the use or management of land within the product system being assessed. The DLUC impacts comprises the emissions and sequestration resulting from carbon stock changes in biomass, dead organic matter and soil organic matters, evaluated in accordance with the IPCC Guidelines. When available, sector or country-specific data on carbon stocks may be used; otherwise, IPCC's Tier 1 default emission factors may be considered. Two terms in the WtT Equation (1) capture respectively emissions resulting from direct land use change, i.e. el, and sequestration or otherwise increase in the content of soil organic carbon: esca.

 

4.11     The ILUC definition is based on ISO 14067:2018, described as a change in the use or management of land, which is a consequence of direct land use change, but which occurs outside the product system being assessed. ILUC occurs as a result of the economic impacts induced by increased biofuel demand on commodity prices with resulting shifts in demand and supply across economic sectors, including primarily food and feed production. ILUC cannot be directly measured and is projected with economic models instead.

 

4.12     Owing to the variability of assumptions underlying the evaluation of indirect effects, quantitative assessment of GHG effects of ILUC is subject to uncertainty, high quantitative variability and to the risk of arbitrary conclusions. For these reasons, ILUC should be at this stage addressed using a risk-based approach, meaning that quantitative values will not be calculated and assigned to each fuel pathway. The ILUC emissions, as well as the spatial dimension of the ILUC effects, are dependent on a variety of factors such as local/regional conditions and practices for agriculture, current and expected food import demand, national current accounts, the type of feedstock, the alternative economic uses of the same feedstock, etc.

 

4.13     A qualitative risk-based approach to ILUC includes consideration on the following:

 

.1       Low-ILUC risk qualifies and characterizes biofuel production projects that supply additional feedstock without disrupting existing land uses. When productivity is increased on an area which is in agricultural production, only additional yields should be considered as low-ILUC rather than the entire production; and

 

.2       High-ILUC risk qualifies and characterizes biofuel production projects based on, or displacing, food and feed crops resulting in a significant expansion of the feedstock production area shifting into land with high carbon stock.

 

4.14     WtT default emission factors are provided in appendix 2 of these guidelines.

 

5          TANK-TO-WAKE (TtW)

 

5.1       The aim of the TtW methodology is to quantify and evaluate the intensity of CO2, CH4 and N2O emitted on board a ship related to the fuel usage, including combustion/conversion and all relevant fugitive emissions, from the bunker manifold up to the energy converter which is leaked, vented or otherwise lost in the system, with a global warming potential.

 

5.2       The TtW GHG emission factors should be calculated using Equation (2):

 

 

 Note: Terms 𝑆𝐹𝑐𝑐𝑢, 𝑒𝑐𝑐𝑢 and 𝑒𝑜𝑐𝑐𝑠 are pending further methodological guidance to be developed by the Organization. For more details refer to footnotes 11 to 13.

 

Term

Units

Explanation

Cslip_ship

% of total fuel mass

Factor accounting for fuel (expressed in % of total fuel mass delivered to the ship) which escapes from the energy converter without being oxidized (including fuel that escapes from combustion chamber/oxidation process and from crankcase, as appropriate)

𝐶𝑠𝑙𝑖𝑝_𝑠hip = 𝐶𝑠𝑙𝑖𝑝 * (1 - 𝐶𝑓𝑢𝑔/100)

Cslip

% of total fuel mass

Factor accounting for fuel (expressed in % of total fuel mass consumed in the energy converter) which escapes from the energy converter without being oxidized (including fuel that escapes from combustion chamber/oxidation process and from crankcase, as appropriate)

Cfug

% of fuel mass

Factor accounting for the fuel (expressed in % of mass of the fuel delivered to the ship) which escapes between the tanks up to the energy converter which is leaked, vented or otherwise lost in the system7

Csfx

gGHG/g fuel

Factor accounting for the share of GHG in the components of the fuel (expressed in g GHG/g fuel)

Example: for LNG this value is 1

CfCO2

gCO2/g fuel

CO2 emission conversion factor (gCO2/g fuel completely combusted) for emissions of the combustion and/or oxidation process of the fuel used by the ship

CfCH4

gCH4/g fuel

CH4 emission conversion factor (gCH4/g fuel delivered to the ship) for emissions of the combustion and/or oxidation process of the fuel used by the ship8

CfN2O

gN2O/g fuel

N2O emission conversion factor (gN2O/g fuel delivered to the ship) for emissions of the combustion and/or oxidation process of the fuel used by the ship

GWPCH4

gCO2eq/g CH4

Global warming potential of CH4 over 100 years (based on the fifth IPCC Assessment Report 5)9

Definition as per https://www.ipcc.ch/assessmentreport/ar5/