Revoked by MEPC.354(78)
RESOLUTION MEPC.339(76)
(adopted on 17 June 2021)
2021
GUIDELINES ON THE OPERATIONAL CARBON INTENSITY RATING OF SHIPS (CII RATING
GUIDELINES, G4)
THE MARINE ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION COMMITTEE,
RECALLING Article 38(a) of the Convention on the International
Maritime Organization concerning the functions of the Marine Environment
Protection Committee conferred upon it by international conventions for the
prevention and control of marine pollution from ships,
NOTING that it adopted, by resolution MEPC.328(76), the 2021 revised MARPOL Annex
VI, which is expected to enter into force on 1 November 2022 upon its deemed
acceptance on 1 May 2022,
NOTING IN PARTICULAR that the 2021 revised MARPOL Annex VI
contains amendments concerning mandatory goal-based technical and operational
measures to reduce carbon intensity of international shipping,
NOTING FURTHER that regulation 28.6 of MARPOL Annex VI requires
ships to which this regulation apply to determine operational carbon intensity
rating taking into account guidelines developed by the Organization,
RECOGNIZING that the aforementioned amendments to MARPOL Annex VI
require relevant guidelines for uniform and effective implementation of the
regulations,
HAVING CONSIDERED, at its seventy-sixth session, draft 2021
Guidelines on the operational carbon intensity rating of ships (CII rating
guidelines, G4),
1 ADOPTS the 2021
Guidelines on the operational carbon intensity rating of ships (CII rating
guidelines, G4), as set out in the annex to the present resolution;
2 INVITES
Administrations to take the annexed Guidelines into account when developing and
enacting national laws which give force to and implement requirements set forth
in regulation 28.6 of MARPOL Annex VI;
3 REQUESTS the
Parties to MARPOL Annex VI and other Member Governments to bring the annexed
Guidelines to the attention of masters, seafarers, shipowners, ship operators
and any other interested parties;
4 AGREES to keep the
Guidelines under review in light of experience gained with their
implementation, of additional data collected and analysed, and in light of the
review of CII regulations to be completed by the Organization by 1 January 2026
as identified in regulation 28.11 of MARPOL Annex VI.
ANNEX
2021
GUIDELINES ON THE OPERATIONAL CARBON INTENSITY RATING OF SHIPS (CII RATING
GUIDELINES, G4)
1 Introduction
1.1 These Guidelines
provide the methods to assign operational energy efficiency performance ratings
to ships, as referred to in regulation 28 of MARPOL Annex VI. On this basis,
the boundaries for determining a ship’s annual operational carbon intensity
performance from year 2023 to 2030 are also provided.
2 Definitions
2.1 MARPOL means
the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, 1973,
as modified by the Protocols of 1978 and 1997 relating thereto, as amended.
2.2 IMO DCS
means the data collection system for fuel oil consumption of ships referred to
in regulation 28 and related provisions of MARPOL Annex VI.
2.3 For the purpose of
these Guidelines, the definitions in MARPOL Annex VI, as amended, apply.
2.4 Operational
carbon intensity rating means to assign a ranking label from among the five
grades (A, B, C, D and E) to the ship based on the attained annual operational
carbon intensity indicator, indicating a major superior, minor superior,
moderate, minor inferior, or inferior performance level.
3 Framework of the
operational energy efficiency performance rating
3.1 An operational
energy efficiency performance rating should be annually assigned to each ship
to which regulation 28 of MARPOL Annex VI applies, in a transparent and robust
manner, based on the deviation of the attained annual operational carbon
intensity indicator (CII) of a ship from the required value.
3.2 To facilitate the
rating assignment, for each year from 2023 to 2030, four boundaries are defined
for the five-grade rating mechanism, namely superior boundary, lower boundary,
upper boundary, and inferior boundary. Thus, a rating can be assigned through
comparing the attained annual operational CII of a ship with the boundary
values.
3.3 The boundaries are
set based on the distribution of CIIs of individual ships in year 2019. The
appropriate rating boundaries are expected to generate the following results:
the middle 30% of individual ships across the fleet segment, in terms of the
attained annual operational CIIs, are to be assigned rating C, while the upper
20% and further upper 15% of individuals are to be assigned rating D and E
respectively, the lower 20% and further lower 15% of the individuals are to be
assigned rating B and A respectively, as illustrated in figure 1.

Figure
1: Operational energy efficiency performance rating scale
3.4 Given the
incremental operational carbon intensity reduction factors over time, the
boundaries for defining performance ratings should be synchronized accordingly,
although the relative distance between the boundaries should not change. The
rating of a ship would be determined by the attained CII and the predetermined
rating boundaries, rather than the attained CII of other ships. Note that the
distribution of ship individual ratings in a specific year may not be always
identical with the scenario in 2019, where for example 20% may achieve A, 30%
may achieve B, 40% may achieve C, 8% may achieve D and 2% may achieve E in a
given year.
4 Method to
determine the rating boundaries
4.1 The boundaries can
be determined by the required annual operational CII in conjunction with the
vectors, indicating the direction and distance they deviate from the required
value (denoted as dd vectors for easy reference), as illustrated in
figure 2.

Figure
2: dd vectors and rating bands
4.2 Statistically, the dd
vectors depend on the distribution of the attained annual operational CII of
ships of the type concerned, which can be estimated through a quantile
regression, taking data collected through DCS in year 2019 as the sample.
4.3 The quantile
regression model for a specific ship type can be developed as follows:
ln(attained CII) =δ(p) - cln(Capacity) + ε(p) , p ={0.15,0.35,0.50,0.65,0.85} (5)
where Capacity is identical with the one used in the
operation carbon intensity indicator as specified in the Guidelines on
operational carbon intensity indicators and the calculation Annex 13, page 4
methods (G1); p is the typical quantile, meaning the proportion of
observations with a lower
value is p%; δ(p)
is the constant term, and ε(p) is the error term.
4.4 The quantile
regression lines in logarithm form are illustrated in Fig.3.

Figure
3: Quantile regression lines in logarithm form
4.5 Then, the dd vectors
can be calculated based on the estimates of the intercept
, in
accordance with Eq.(2), as follows:
(6)
4.6 Through an
exponential transformation of each dd vector, the four boundaries fitted
in the original data form can be derived based on the required annual
operational carbon intensity indicator (required CII ), as follows: